One if by Land, Two if by Sea

17 Barrow St, New York, NY 10014

Description

Romantic American dining. This upscale American restaurant is known to be one of the city's most romantic.

Features

  • Price: $$$$

Comments

A Shen -

Beautiful and unique space, which is ideal for dates. The food was good, but a bit expensive. The Beef Wellington is the best I've had in the city. Only the Valentine's menu was available when we went, which cost $200 per person and consists of 4 courses. All of the food was good, but not good enough for the price tag in my opinion. The normal Prix Fixe and Tasting Menus are more affordable. Our service was good, and the servers were attentive, but the timing between each course was quite slow. Our server did recognize and apologize for this.

Neha Luthra -

This place is so beautiful and cozy. The staff is wonderful and the room is so elegant. They were playing music when we went for lunch and it was such a wonderful experience. The food was also great! I would definitely recommend coming here: especially for a date. It’s very romantic!

Alex Serebrov -

This is very sophisticated high end place with the history that goes back to 18th century. Perfect for romantic dinner or date night. To be honest I was there for dinner more than 10 years ago, but I visited them recently because they start to have jazz brunch. You have to book it in advance and you will be submerged into atmosphere of 30-40s of the last century. It was very pleasant and romantic the band the singer it was just amazing! As for the food please keep in mind that for the brunch you will have only prefix menu option without ability to choose or order something else. Oh! And jazz invitation includes one free drink.

Zarina -

Very nice place. Caught my eye as I was walking by. Great ambience and atmosphere. Came here to hang out in the bar near the piano man for an intimate experience. Bartender made our drinks amazing. Loved my espresso martini. Piano man plays great music that's a great background for drinks and a great meal. Intimate restaurant. Very nice mood. Highly recommend for a good time whether your here for drinks, a meal, or both.

Richard Devitt -

Our experience was top notch in every regard. The setting and ambiance are very romantic and rustic, and each course was perfectly executed. The cuisine was traditional. The Beef Wellington was the standout; sublime! Perfect place for a date with the one you love.

Angela Rondinella -

Went here with my cousin yo celebrate her retirement. It's definitely more a couples restaurant as the setting is very romantic. Downstairs seemed more for all parties but we unfortunately were not able to sit there. Our waiter Jorge was absolutely amazing. Very attentive and gave great suggestions. The rest of the staff was also very friendly. I had the beef wellington which was delicious. I'll be honest, I'm into the whole ghost phenomenon and was intrigued by the history of this restaurant. Apparently the staff has experienced many ghostly happenings. None for us, just a great meal with an incredible staff. Thank you!

Dylan James -

Had an absolutely lovely evening celebrating an anniversary here. The live piano player is an elegant touch. The food was sensational, the service impeccable (thank you Tai), and the ambience cozy and romantic. It was a night out to remember for sure.

C B -

The atmosphere is beautiful with candle lights and live piano. Service is also good, although a little overattentive at times (they tried to take away our plates before we had finished a few times). We got the 7 courses menu ($160). The food is generally good, but only some things are exceptional. I really liked the tuna sashimi and the single scallop. The fish and beef were good but nothing spectacular. What really disappointed is the cheese platter that reminds me of the box you get at the airport when your flight is delayed (see picture). Overall, it was enjoyable but I probably won't go back.

Write a Review

Review your experience


17 Barrow St, New York, NY 10014
(212) 255-8649
Monday
5:30 - 02:00:00
Tuesday
5:30 - 02:00:00
Wednesday
5:30 - 02:00:00
Thursday
5:30 - 02:00:00
Friday
02:00:00 - 02:00:00
Saturday
02:00:00 - 02:00:00
Sunday
5:30 - 02:00:00

Recent Places