Pisillo Italian Panini

Cash only. Solid $20 sandwich that will last you at least 2 meals. Got the flagship #26 Pisillo for lunch. Had a lot of great flavor variety and really lets the prosciutto stand out. I was recommended Ciabatta bread. IMHO, a good amount of filling. Bread is a little too hard. Warming of the sandwich would probably help it. It is extremely large and I had the second half for dinner. I'd still give the edge to DISO's for softer bread, more variety, warm sandwiches, slightly better pricing. However you can't go wrong if you have cash and are nearby.

Really awesome sandwiches!! Very delicious. Tons of sandwich option to please anybody’s appetite. This place is only cash only so bring some cash. The service was friendly and fast. Definitely check this place out. I highly recommend this place.

Been trying to get down here ever since my buddy informed me that the sister spot in Chelsea made incredible sandwiches. Light work day for a Friday so I rounded up some coworkers to take a walk to the shop. It's Cash Only with an ATM in the establishment if you are short of cash. I believe the boss was working the slicer. I got the #1 The Milano on the white roll, under $20, weighed about 5lbs and it was absolutely delicious. I couldn't finish the whole sandwich, only able to eat half so I saved the rest for dinner. It was still delicious about 7 hours later.

Italian Sandwiches That will feed you for days! My sandwich was 3 days of meals and I love to eat, it was just too huge! Go for a sandwich and know you will be able to eat leftovers! So I will start with this, if you are a vegetarian, you an eat here and Pisillo DOES NOT SKIMP on anything unlike other places with veggie hoagies and cheese. Now, as an Italian Chica, this was my jam. Stacked and large. Fresh ingredients and just plain good. The only real negative is that there are really only 4 tables in there, which if they were busy, would not be a good thing, but we were there after lunch rush so we got seats! The owner is wonderful and helpful. Bread is as fresh as could be with a good exterior crunch and then the ingredients inside the bread take care of the rest! The Ancona is as good on Day 1 as it is on Day3! There are 35+ sandwich options or you can make your own. It's CASH ONLY but there is also an ATM right inside. 4 sandwiches + 4 cans of soda were about $75 - Everyone was so stuffed and NONE of us, even the biggest foodie in our group could finish their sandwich! So rather than fried garbage or a mini sandwich that will cost you the same, this FIDI (Nassau St) sandwich shop is the winner! Get it to-go and enjoy!

Huge deli sandwich’s! Very tasty and great ingredients. Great spot for a quick lunch x they have small tables inside, but there’s not a ton of room.

Oh man. You're not going to ever come back to NYC and not make time to hit Pisillo. It was as amazing as it looks. I'm so happy. I got the Palermo on focaccia. I'm heading back soon. Highly recommend.

So glad we found this spot! The $1 extra for the bread was worth it. Plenty of meat and fresh ingredients. I recommend sharing with people because the portions are huge and you can try different ones! Not pictured on this sandwhich because I was already eating it, BUT GET THE ROASTED PEPPERS.

First time here I ordered the #17 Trieste, this cost $14.90. When I arrived to the store it said cash only, so I had to use the app so it came out to $19. The sandwich was pretty good. I would’ve liked more balsamic for next time. The semolina bread was soft and tasty.